When Overthinking Starts Rewriting the Story

Have you ever walked away from a conversation feeling perfectly fine, only to replay it later and decide that actually, it was a complete disaster? Perhaps somebody didn’t reply quite as warmly as usual, there was a pause that suddenly feels significant, or you remember something you said three hours ago and think, Why on earth did I say that? Before long, your mind has taken a fairly ordinary interaction, pulled it apart, examined every word and facial expression and produced an entirely new version of events. Welcome to overthinking.

When thinking becomes overthinking

Thinking things through can be useful. It helps us solve problems, understand experiences and make decisions. Overthinking is different. Instead of moving us towards an answer, our thoughts start going around in circles. Did I say the wrong thing? Why did they respond like that? Perhaps they’re annoyed with me. I knew I shouldn’t have said anything. What if I’ve made everything worse?

The difficulty is that the longer we think about something, the more convincing our interpretation can become. Eventually, we can stop asking “What actually happened?” and start responding to the story our mind has created about what happened.

Our memories aren’t recordings

We sometimes imagine memory works a little like CCTV — that somewhere in our brain is an accurate recording of events that we can simply replay. It doesn’t quite work like that. Memory is reconstructive. When we remember something, our brain rebuilds the experience using pieces of information, previous experiences, emotions and what we currently understand about the situation.

That means the way we remember an event can sometimes be influenced by how we’re feeling now. If you’re already worried that somebody is upset with you, you may remember their expression as more negative. If you’re feeling rejected, an unanswered message may suddenly seem like evidence that somebody doesn’t care. If a relationship has become difficult, previous conversations can begin to look different when viewed through what you know today.

That doesn’t mean you’re inventing memories or deliberately changing what happened. It means memory and interpretation are more complicated than simply pressing replay.

When feelings start becoming evidence

One of the traps of overthinking is that feelings can begin to feel like proof. I feel embarrassed, therefore I must have embarrassed myself. I feel guilty, therefore I must have done something wrong. I feel rejected, therefore they must be rejecting me.

But feelings and facts aren’t always the same thing. Your feelings are real and deserve attention. They tell us something important about how an experience has affected you, but they don’t necessarily tell us exactly what another person thought, intended or meant. That distinction can be surprisingly powerful.

What CBT can bring to overthinking

CBT — Cognitive Behavioural Therapy — looks at the relationship between our thoughts, feelings and behaviour. One useful part of CBT is learning to slow down automatic thoughts and examine them rather than immediately accepting them as facts.

You might ask yourself what you actually know, what you are assuming, whether there is another reasonable explanation and what you would say to somebody you cared about if they were thinking the same thing. This isn’t about replacing every uncomfortable thought with a cheerful one. Sometimes something genuinely did go badly and sometimes somebody really is unhappy with us. The aim isn’t to convince ourselves that everything is wonderful. It’s to look at the situation as fairly as we can rather than allowing anxiety to fill every gap with the worst possible explanation.

Overthinking can affect what happens next

Overthinking doesn’t always stay inside our heads. If you become convinced somebody is annoyed with you, you might withdraw. You might repeatedly ask whether everything is okay, apologise when you haven’t actually done anything wrong, or become defensive because you’re expecting criticism that hasn’t actually happened.

The other person then responds to that behaviour, and suddenly a problem that originally existed mainly in our thoughts can begin affecting the relationship itself. Understanding that pattern isn’t about blaming yourself. It’s about recognising where you might have some choice over what happens next.

How Therapy With Gail can help

At Therapy With Gail, we can explore what sits underneath your overthinking rather than simply telling you to “stop worrying”, because if stopping were that easy, you probably would have done it already. We might look at situations that repeatedly trigger the overthinking, the assumptions you make about yourself or other people, previous experiences that may influence how you interpret situations now, and what happens when uncertainty feels difficult to tolerate.

My approach combines a Person-Centred foundation with CBT where it is useful. That means there is space to understand why something matters to you, not simply challenge every thought you have. We can also use practical CBT techniques to separate what you know from what you fear, recognise repeated thinking patterns and develop different ways of responding when your mind starts running several miles ahead of the available evidence.

Importantly, therapy isn’t about me telling you what the “correct” version of events is. It’s about helping you become more able to trust yourself while remaining open to the possibility that your first interpretation isn’t the only one.

Something to try when your mind starts rewriting the story

When you notice yourself replaying an interaction, try separating what happened from what your mind has added to it. Ask yourself: What actually happened? What have I interpreted? What don’t I know yet? For the first question, stick to what somebody watching the situation could actually have seen or heard. Then notice the meaning you’ve added and, finally, identify the things you simply cannot know.

That last part can be difficult because sometimes the most accurate answer really is I don’t know. Although uncertainty can feel uncomfortable, “I don’t know” can sometimes be much kinder to ourselves than automatically filling the gap with the worst possible explanation.

If overthinking is taking up too much space in your life, affecting your relationships or making you continually question yourself, Therapy With Gail can help you understand the pattern and find a different way of responding to it. You don’t have to think your way out of overthinking on your own.

Therapy With Gail
Counselling that makes room for real life, difficult conversations and the things we don’t always know how to say.