Why Do I Always Think the Worst? Understanding Catastrophising

Why Do I Always Think the Worst? Understanding Catastrophising

The phone rings unexpectedly and your first thought is that something terrible has happened. Your manager asks if they can have a word and, before you’ve even reached the meeting, you’ve mentally lost your job. You notice an unusual physical sensation and ten minutes later you’re imagining the worst possible diagnosis.

Nothing terrible has actually happened yet. But your mind is already there, several chapters ahead, dealing with the disaster.

This is often called catastrophising — a thinking pattern where we predict or focus on a particularly negative outcome and begin responding emotionally as though it is likely, or sometimes inevitable.

When “might” quietly becomes “will”

Catastrophising often starts with something that is genuinely possible. That’s partly why it can be so convincing. Your manager could want to discuss a problem. An unexplained symptom could need medical attention. A person who hasn’t replied to you could be upset.

The difficulty comes when “this might happen” becomes “this probably will happen”, and then very quickly becomes “and I won’t cope when it does.”

Our bodies can join in too. Anxiety can cause very real physical sensations — a racing heart, tension, butterflies, sweating or that horrible feeling in the pit of your stomach. Those sensations can then seem like further evidence that something really is wrong.

Before long, we’re not simply considering a possibility. We’re experiencing the fear of an event that hasn’t actually happened.

Why does the mind do this?

Our brains are rather good at looking for potential threats. Being able to anticipate danger has obvious advantages. The problem is that modern life provides an enormous number of uncertainties for that threat-detection system to work with.

An unanswered email, a change in somebody’s tone, an unexpected bill, a medical appointment or a difficult conversation can all leave gaps in our knowledge. When we’re anxious, stressed or already feeling vulnerable, our minds can fill those gaps with the most threatening explanation available.

Sometimes we also believe that worrying prepares us. If we’ve already imagined every possible disaster, perhaps nothing can catch us off guard.

Unfortunately, repeatedly rehearsing the worst possible outcome doesn’t necessarily make us better prepared. Quite often, it simply means we experience the distress before we even know whether there is anything to be distressed about.

When reassurance only works for a little while

Catastrophising can also lead us to seek reassurance. We ask somebody what they think, search online, reread messages or check something repeatedly until we feel a little calmer.

There is nothing wrong with seeking information or reassurance when we genuinely need it. The difficulty is when reassurance provides relief for only a short time before the doubt returns.

Someone tells us, “I’m sure it’s fine.”

We feel better.

Then the mind says, Yes, but what if they’re wrong?

So we check again.

The reassurance reduces the anxiety temporarily, but it can also make it harder to tolerate uncertainty the next time it appears.

What CBT can help us do

CBT — Cognitive Behavioural Therapy — can be particularly useful for recognising catastrophising because it helps us slow down the jump from an uncertain situation to the worst possible conclusion.

Rather than telling yourself you’re being ridiculous or trying to force yourself to think positively, you can become curious about what your mind is predicting. You might ask yourself: What am I predicting? What evidence do I actually have? Are there other reasonable explanations? If the difficult thing did happen, what could I do?

That final question is important. Catastrophising isn’t only about overestimating how likely something bad is to happen. We can also underestimate our ability to deal with it.

You may have coped with difficult things before. You may have people you could turn to, decisions you could make or support you could access. Remembering that doesn’t guarantee a particular outcome. It simply puts your own ability to respond back into the picture.

This isn’t about pretending everything will be fine

The opposite of catastrophising isn’t telling yourself, Everything will definitely be wonderful.

None of us can promise ourselves that.

Difficult things happen. Relationships end. People become ill. Jobs change. Plans fail. Life occasionally delivers things we would very much rather it didn’t.

A more balanced response might be: “I don’t know exactly what will happen, but I don’t currently have evidence that disaster is inevitable — and if something difficult happens, I can deal with it when it happens.”

That may not sound as comforting as “everything will be fine”, but it has something important going for it: you don’t have to convince yourself of something you cannot know.

How Therapy With Gail can help

If your mind regularly races towards the worst possible outcome, Therapy With Gail can help you understand what is happening rather than simply telling you to stop worrying.

We can explore the situations that trigger these thoughts, what uncertainty feels like for you and whether previous experiences have influenced how you respond when you don’t know what is going to happen. Sometimes catastrophising sits alongside anxiety or overthinking. Sometimes it appears particularly strongly around relationships, work, health, family or periods of change.

My Person-Centred approach means there is room to understand your experience rather than treating you as a collection of unhelpful thoughts that need correcting. Where it is useful, I can also draw on CBT to help you recognise thinking patterns, examine the evidence around your predictions and find more balanced ways of responding.

The aim isn’t to turn you into someone who never worries. Worry is part of being human, particularly when something matters to us.

It’s about helping the possibility of something going wrong remain a possibility, rather than allowing it to become tomorrow’s disaster before tomorrow has even arrived.

So, the next time your mind races ten steps ahead, perhaps ask yourself one question:

Am I responding to what is actually happening, or to what I’m frightened might happen?

Sometimes there really is something that needs dealing with. Sometimes there isn’t.

And if distinguishing between the two has become difficult, Therapy With Gail can help you slow things down, understand the pattern and find a different way of responding to uncertainty.

Therapy With Gail
Counselling that makes room for real life, difficult conversations and the things we don’t always know how to say.